Alexander M. Bickel , The Morality of Consent 77, 78 (1975) (commenting on Holmes's marketplaceofideas theory); see also Alexander M. Bickel , The Least Dangerous Branch: The Supreme Court at the Bar of Politics 9298 (1962) (discussing "benevolent illusions"). To the best of our computer assisted knowledge, the epigraph has never been quoted in the American law review literature.
Bickel's larger point, of course, transcended First Amendment theory to encompass constitutional jurisprudence and political philosophy.
Ronald K.L. Collins & David M. Skover , The Death of Discourse 252 n.2 (1996).
Consider generally Alexander Nehamas , Nietzsche: Life as Literature 22 41 (1985) (discussing rhetorical tropes in Nietzsche's writing).
James Boyd White , When Words Lose Their Meaning 264 (1984).
Consider generally Nehamas , supra note 6, at 13, 22, 28, 31 (noting relationship between Nietzsche's thinking and his writing style); Niccolo Machiavelli , The Prince 5, 8, 10, 22 (Martin Coyle ed., Manchester Univ. Press 1996) (Machiavelli's style).
John Donne, An Anatomy of the World , in The Complete Poetry of John Donne lines 20708 (John T. Shawcross ed., New York Univ. Press 1968).
Shadia Drury, Lying and Politics , 64 U. Cin. L. Rev. 1227, 1228 (1996).
David Nyberg, Noble Lies, Narrative Truths, and The Art of Voice: Thoughts on Pragmatic Language and the First Amendment , 64 U. Cin. L. Rev. 1203, 1206 (1996).
Robert Hariman, Machiavelli at the Fair , 64 U. Cin. L. Rev. 1237, 1242 (1996).
See generally Richard Rorty , Contingency, Irony, and Solidarity (1989). When asked to comment on the excesses of Western culture, Professor Rorty once replied, "I think it's the best little culture anybody ever thought of. It will appear to our remote descendants pretty crude, primitive and nasty, but as cultures go these days it's terrific." Martyn Oliver, Towards a Liberal Utopia: An Interview with Richard Rorty , Times Literary Supplement , June 24, 1994, at 14.
See generally Stanley Fish , There's No Such Thing as Free Speech and It's a Good Thing, Too (1994).
Collins & Skover , supra note 4, at 109, 110 (quoting, in part, Jules Henry).
To be fair, there are passages in which Professors Nyberg and Hariman suggest that the theorypractice gap may not be as wide as we depict it. See, e.g. , Nyberg, supra note 13, at 1217; Hariman, supra note 14, at 1247 48. Such arguments presume, however, that there are pockets of private and public expression that are largely immune from the ubiquitous influences of our mass commercial entertainment culture. In this regard, see Collins & Skover , supra note 4, at 2223, 77, 153, 20103.
Sue Curry Jansen , Censorship: The Knot that Binds Power and Knowledge 203 (1991). Remarkably, this most thoughtful work on censorship has yet to receive the attention it richly deserves in the legal literature.
Id. at 248; cf. Dennis F. Thompson, Hypocrisy and Democracy , in Liberalism Without Illusions: Essays on Liberal Theory & the Political Vision of Judith N. Shklar 17390 (Bernard Yack ed., 1996) (offering one explanatory interpretation of the passage quoted in the text).
Virtually all of our colleagues in this Symposium confine their comments on lying or hypocrisy to a defense of modern liberalism, i.e. , "narratives" that accord First Amendment protection in the name of high ideals. What is overlooked, however, is our discussion of respectable stories employed by radical feminists to withdraw First Amendment protection from pornography. See Collins & Skover , supra note 4, at 17984, 19699. What are we to make of our colleagues's silence here? Only Professor Drury addresses, albeit obliquely, the matter by noting, "Radical feminists are particularly notorious for their creative lies." Drury, supra note 11, at 1234. On this score, what are we to make of the fact that the radical feminists alone are tagged as deliberate liars?
Todd Gitlin , The Twilight of Common Dreams: Why America is Wracked by Culture Wars 214 (1995).
Leo Strauss , Liberalism: Ancient and Modern 85 (1968). However understandable in these times, it is not axiomatic that because one invokes the thought of the late Professor Strauss one is thereby a "Straussian" or views the world through a "Straussian lens," whatever those charges may mean. In this regard, consider, for example, Stanley Rosen , Plato's Symposium xivxv (2d ed. 1987).
Somewhat puzzled, we ask our colleagues: Was the wizard a wonderful story teller? An imaginative myth maker? A confused narrator? A profound philosopher? A deliberate liar? Or all of the above?
On a more general level, Professor Drury does not seem
to be entirely troubled by hypocrisy in the First Amendment context because she believes
that such hypocrisy is readily detectable. For example, "Restrictions on advertising
and pornography are quite compatible with the intentions of Madisonian discourse . . . .
When cigarette companies complain that the restrictions imposed on their advertising rob
them of their freedom of speech, no one takes their argument seriously; their lie is so
blatant that it fools no one." Drury, supra note 11, at 1230. Argued as a worthy
classicist.
Conceptually, withholding First Amendment protection from advertising and pornography in
today's mass commercial entertainment culture is not as uncomplicated as Professor Drury
might have us believe. Advertising and pornography are no longer, if they ever were,
insular categories that can be surgically removed from the body of our culture. The
commingling of the commercial and noncommercial is so extensive that what was once
"blatant" is now "blatant" and "mainstream" at the same
time. This blending is so significant that Americans now define their very lifestyles and
identities in terms of commodities. See Collins & Skover , supra note 4, at 8889,
11415. To be unmindful of these points is to allow a form of censorship in modern
America tantamount to tyranny. Of course, the specter of censorship prompts some
"Enlightenment" liberals to tolerate hypocrisy.
Johann Wolfgang von Goethe , The Sufferings of Young Werther & Elective Affinities 238 (Victor Lange ed. & Elizabeth Mayer & Louise Bogan trans., 1990) (from Elective Affinities ).
See generally Mary Ann Dzuback , Robert M. Hutchins: Portrait of an Educator (1991).
Loyal Rue, After the Death of Discourse , 64 U. Cin. L. Rev. 1277, 128990 (1996).
Michael F. Jacobson & Laurie Ann Mazur , Marketing Madness: A Survival Guide for a Consumer Society 29, 30 (1995).
Id . at 30 (quoting UNPLUG, A National Youth Organization for Commercial Free Equitable Education , press release, Oct. 19, 1993) (emphasis deleted).
Paul Farhi, Public TV's Private Ordeal: As Funding Growth Slows, PBS Casts Its Eye on Commercial Ties , Wash. Post , Mar. 17, 1996, at H1. For a more extensive account, see generally Williams Hoynes , Public Television for Sale: Media, the Market, and the Public Sphere (1994).
Where Madison Avenue Meets the Schoolhouse , N.Y. Times , Feb. 28, 1996, at B8.
Barry Schwartz , The Costs of Living: How Market Freedom Erodes the Best Things in Life 184 (1994).
This, at least, is what one great liberal educator, Dr. Alexander Meiklejohn, urged. For it was this president of Amherst College, later chairman of the Experimental College at Wisconsin, who declared adamantly that the First Amendment ought not safeguard commercial speech. See Alexander Meiklejohn , Political Freedom: The Constitutional Powers of the People xvxvi, 8688 (reprint, 1979).
Rosen , supra note 8, at 138. Professor Rosen concludes the observation quoted in the text with the following: "and never more so than in times of extreme decadence." Id.
Richard Stivers, Technology, Discourse, and Truth , 64 U. Cin. L. Rev. 1259, 1267 (1996).
Professor Rue does offer a modest variation of his biocultural approach, one calling for local regulation of pornography and federal luxury taxes. Id. at 128088. But ultimately, he concedes that such an approach may be "well beyond the realm of possibility, for how could such proposals gather support in a culture where the target of legislation gets to ration the bullets and determine who shoots?" Id. at 128889.
Friedrich Nietzsche , On the Pathos of Truth (1872), in Philosophical Writings 85 (Reinhold Grimm and Caroline Molina y Vedia eds. & Bruce Armstrong trans., 1995). Of course, we are not accusing our colleagues of being "Nietzschean," whatever that may mean.
See Collins & Skover , supra note 4, at xxixxv, 199202, 21115.
William Labov, Narrative Analysis: Oral Versions of Personal Experience , in American Ethnological Society , Essays on the Verbal and Visual Arts: Proceedings of the American Ethnological Society 3738 (June Helm ed., 1967).
See Anthony Lewis , Make No Law: The Sullivan Case and the First Amendment 14052 (Random House, Inc. 1991); id. at 153 (noting that New York Times v. Sullivan was the "first full statement by the Supreme Court as a whole of an American theory of free speech: the Madisonian theory").
As to where we may meet next, see (if you will) the website for The Death of Discourse.