If [our values] are lies, they are . . . true lies;
if illusions, then indispensable ones.
To abandon them is to commit moral suicide.

­Alexander M. Bickel
1

We begin with Bickel.

Back in 1973, he spoke those words at Yale Law School. Bickel had free speech theory in mind. The renowned constitutional scholar posed a paradox: lies may be vital to the life of the First Amendment. 2

To some, perhaps most, this complex passage sounds odd, especially coming from the lips of the counselor recruited by the New York Times in the Pentagon Papers case. 3 For it was in that controversy between government and press that the foreign­born Bickel vindicated a basic tenet of American democracy­ deception is antithetical to the First Amendment.

As far as we can say, Bickel never resolved the tension between lies and First Amendment values that he so poignantly identified. Regrettably, his reflections on free speech theory ended with his untimely death one year after his Yale lecture. He never told us how lies could be true, or exactly why illusions are indispensable. No, he left those questions unanswered and slipped gently into the night.

prevnav.gif (1564 bytes)
Previous

homenav.gif (1574 bytes)
Article Index

nextnav.gif (1624 bytes)
Next