Prefatory Comments

This Symposium invites us to pick up where Professor Bickel left off. It presents an opportunity to return to the "sketch" 4 of the topic explored in the Epilogue of The Death of Discourse. That sketch introduced perplexing connections among lying, free speech theory, and political philosophy. We had hoped that others would subsequently draw more detailed portraits. Happily, our colleagues in this Symposium have done just that, and colorfully so.

If for no other reason, this Symposium is important because it features the ideas of scholars, outside the law, on values within the law of the First Amendment. As we emphasize in our book, discourse on free speech stands to benefit considerably from the contributions of those who think beyond the letter of the law. This is entirely consistent with the notion in The Death of Discourse that the First Amendment is more than law­it is a way of life.

A few more prefatory comments. The Death of Discourse is far less categorical and far more provisional than is apparent at first glance. Indeed, we encourage our readers throughout to engage in a dialogue with us. 5 Among other things, we pose questions, shift perspectives, fashion bold and seductive claims, 6 and move the discourse in and out of exchanges with our Dramatis Personae­much in the interest of a "collective process of conversation and judgment." 7 We feel compelled to make this disclosure because depictions of our work as closed, static, or dogmatic summon us to defend a book that we did not write.

Several of our colleagues in this Symposium address the role and rule of "narrative" in the First Amendment context. Judging from their statements, they dwell on the substance of narrative to the virtual exclusion of narrative style . Yet, one might discern a good deal about narrative plot from narrative form . After all, "no text worth reading wears its meaning on its sleeve." 8 For whatever reasons, our colleagues generally decline to address such methods of argument in The Death of Discourse. Hence, it would be premature for us to proceed too far with these telling matters. For now, our cerebral flirt should suffice to catch the mind's eye of the attentive reader. 9

prevnav.gif (1564 bytes)
Previous

homenav.gif (1574 bytes)
Article Index

nextnav.gif (1624 bytes)
Next