Paideia vs. Profit
If education is to rescue us, then to what end? Is it first and foremost paideia, the shaping of character to develop wellinformed and socially responsible citizens? Or is it rather job training in the service of economic selfinterest and pleasure? In this regard, psychology professor Barry Schwartz reminds us that "the moral character of a culture is bound up with our judgment of the set of practices that the culture encourages and supports." 60 In a society that teaches its future citizens to be entrepreneurs and consumers, "the good person becomes the good pursuer of wealth." 61 It is nearly tautological: a culture that highly values commerce will teach, above all, the values of commerce.
Even if our colleagues's campaign were to succeed and education were to be essentially purged of all of commercialism's contaminations, it is puzzling to imagine what that education would be like. To reinvigorate Madisonian values, would education return civic republicanism to the public mind? But then what? Would we defend the fundamental right of all to all forms of expression, and teach the need to tolerate the base? Seemingly, this education would never move the commercial entertainment culture beyond the point where it is now, or ward off the Huxleyan dilemma 62 to which it is tending. Or would we emphasize the need to combat the base, and thus withhold constitutional protection from expression inimical to our high ideals? 63 Seemingly, this education flirts with the censorship associated with Orwellian regimes. In the end, have our colleagues not reintroduced in the guise of educational reform their own version of what we labeled the "Paratroopers' Paradox?" 64