Taking Flight
[F]earless thinking has fearless consequences . . . .
Stanley Rosen 65
We now leave the valleys of narrative truths, hypocrisy, and deliberate lies, and take flight toward the heights where Professors Loyal Rue and Richard Stivers would have us soar. For this mission no Piper Cubs will do; bring out the F14A Tomcats. We are, after all, entering the realm of fearless thinking.
Professors Rue and Stivers maneuver around the topic of First Amendment deliberate lies for two basic reasons. First, they believe that Madisonian principles are virtually irrelevant in our highly technological and entertainmentdriven society. Second, they understand The Death of Discourse to be about more, far more, than America's free speech system. Ultimately, they admonish us: we must never forget that it is a civilization we are examining.
"We have now reached the turning point," Professor Stivers asserts. 66 " [T]he probability of a return to Madisonian ideals is small indeed and will take more than a shocking discourse, even if this is the necessary first step." 67 In ways unimaginable to Madison's generation, modern technology has seized an immense power over our laws, discourse, and culture. So great is that power that " [n]othing short of a nonviolent cultural revolution, no matter how unlikely it may be, will allow us to escape the modern tyranny of technology." 68 Essentially, Stivers's technological critique moves us from talk about First Amendment reforms to talk about the transformation of America as a civilization.
Similarly, Professor Rue calls on us to think beyond that "relatively minor document" 69 known as the First Amendment so that "we are brought to the heart of the matter: is it too late to save the American experiment of self governance?" 70 For Rue, not only is the American experiment not sacred, but ultimately, it is not worth saving. In a society so ecologically imbalanced and so selfindulgent, even modest reforms are improbable, if only because they stand to be judged as tyrannical. 71 Thus, Professor Rue bids " 'good riddance' to the American Dream," a social experiment that has "miserably failed." 72 With deliberative irreverence, he quips: "The patch of land between Mexico and Canada might become the former United States of America. Okay, so what's all the fuss about? It's bound to happen sooner or later, so why not sooner?" 73