Education for the Marketplace
Skepticism is amply warranted. If education is to combat rampant commercialism and the like, educators must be mindful of how commercialism pervades education on various fronts. On the operational front, public elementary and secondary school districts are trading more and more with marketers to overcome the constraints of tightening instructional budgets:
More than eight million of our nation's students are tuned in daily to Channel Onethe station that pumps ads into classroomsthis despite protests by the National Education Association and the National PTA. 54 Over 12,000 American high schools (accounting for forty percent of high school students) are a captive audience for that channel. 55 A 1993 demographic study of Channel One schools revealed that "schools with the greatest concentration of lowincome students are more than twice as likely as the schools with the wealthiest students to have Channel One." 56
American corporations by the thousands supply curricular and extra curricular materials, from teacher's forestry guides prepared by Weyerhaeuser with selfserving "instructional" questions, to adladen book covers, to corporate logos on athletic uniforms and in athletic facilities. 57
In response to its shrinking sources of funding, America's nonprofit educational television, the Public Broadcasting Service, is quickly becoming a marketplace playerpeddling its greatest hits through homeshopping catalogues, joining arms with MCI Communications Corporation to hawk CDROMs and with the Turner Home Entertainment division to market videotapes, and licensing the PBS logo to manufacturers of "educational" products. 58
Anecdotal evidence tells the story even more strikingly. Palmer High School in Colorado Springs, for example, supplements its revenue by leasing school property to corporate advertisers. Hanging a sixfootlong banner inside the school costs a marketer $700 per year; for $2,500, corporate logos can be painted on the side of a yellow school bus. With "plenty of blank wall space left to fill," Superintendent of Schools Kenneth Burnley boasts that the district is "just scratching the surface of potential revenue." 59 Banners and buses today, walls, lockers, bulletin boards, desks, chalk boards, book pages, and computer screens tomorrow.
Lest we be misunderstood, our larger point is that commerce's many threads are interwoven more and more into the fabric of American education. While our classrooms are not yet overtaken by commercialism, there are discernible trends in that direction. Such trends are antithetical to instilling the ethical values of republican simplicity, those of Adams, Jefferson, Emerson, Thoreau, and the like. Hence, on the ideological front, the commercialization of our schools is likely to redefine the aspirational goals of the "good life." When students are educated less about civics and more about commerce, less about selfrestraint and more about unbridled liberty, and less about public virtue and more about private gain, the lessons of the marketplace become the lessons of the schoolhouse. Whatever else, this is not education in sophrosyne (sobriety, moderation).