Escaping the Paratroopers' Paradox

Consider this: " [D]isdain of that which belongs to the present moment is an integral part of philosophical contemplation." 74

Bold statements, gentlemen. "Hyperbolic" or not, such reflections engage The Death of Discourse in two important dialogic ways. First, they begin (explicitly or otherwise) to play out the consequences of our "cultural approach" to the First Amendment. 75 The cultural approach, as we sketch it, may extend to Stivers's sociological claims about technology and to Rue's ecological claims about civilization. Our approach need not validate these claims in order to recognize the value in seriously considering them. Such thinking is made possible, of course, precisely because our colleagues' discourse about the First Amendment covers the terrain from Orwellian tyranny to Huxleyan tyranny, and beyond­a journey never ventured by "dunderheads." 76

Second, both Professors Rue and Stivers escape the paradox of the traditional First Amendment as formulated in The Death of Discourse. They do so, however, by denying the relevancy of Madisonian ideals and challenging the viability of Madisonian government. Fundamentally, our colleagues appreciate our hypothesis that the traditional First Amendment cannot save itself without destroying itself. In the spirit of Albert Camus, they engage us in a "discourse of death." 77

We leave it to you, the readers of this Symposium, to decide whether our colleagues have brought their terrifying Tomcats in for a safe landing, or whether they have parachuted. You be the judge.

prevnav.gif (1564 bytes)
Previous

homenav.gif (1574 bytes)
Article Index

nextnav.gif (1624 bytes)
Next