Toward a View of Narrative "Truth"
The sun is lost, and th'earth, and no mans wit
Can well direct him, where to looke for it.
John Donne 10
Considering how several of our colleagues characterize our passion for truth, we are reminded of a fetching quip: "Tell your boss what you think of her, and the truth will set you free." Not only may we be unable to afford the truth, but, in our postmodern world, truth is a virtual reality. Either way, truth is troublesome.
Predictably, our colleagues are troubled by the image attributed to us as truthtellers:
True to their convictions, these colleagues seem to devalue the pursuit of truth. Some of them can be understood as urging us to move away from the Enlightenment's notion of truthseekinga paradigm in which truths are both real and discernible. By the same token, they can be read as inviting us to move toward a view of "narrative truth"a paradigm in which "truths" have currency as satisfying stories.
To all appearances, Professor Nyberg appeals to narrative truths as epistemological criteria for First Amendment theory. Nyberg argues that "Madisonian First Amendment conservatorship can be better described in many if not most instances as based upon narrative truth (granted its fictional and deceptive qualities) . . . ." 15 Does not something of this mindset likewise inform Professor Hariman's suggestion that Madisonian rationality is the "wrong standard"? Thus, we " 'feel' the irrelevance of the model of Madisonian speech" given the "radical relativism within modern society . . . ." 16 And it is precisely this philosophical position that prompts Professor Drury to protest that "the postmodern world has dispensed with truth . . . . In a world where reality and truth are a void, the creative art rules supreme." 17