Enlightenment Truth vs. Narrative "Truth"
The Enlightenment and narrative concepts of truth, however similar they may appear, are
as different as Aristotle and Madison on the one hand, and Rorty 18 and Fish 19
on the other. Essentially, the move from Enlightenment truth to narrative truth parallels
the transition from the modern to the postmodern. This transition substitutes aesthetics
for foundationalism; "that art is worth more than truth is the dominant principle of
our time." 20
Too much talk of narrative can be dizzying. In order better to target the discussion,
we offer the following defining points in rapidfire:
- Madisonian ideals are anchored in Enlightenment truths. By contrast, narrative truths
afford no safe harbor for Enlightenment truths.
- In principle and practice, traditional Madisonian values war with pluralistic narrative
truths and varying aesthetic judgments.
- One defender of Madisonian idealswhom we call the classicist 21 is intolerant of those corruptive
influences of the popular commercial culture that invite Huxleyan tyranny. 22 By contrast, the defender of narrative
truthssomewhat like the free speech advocate we call the modernist 23 tolerates a great measure of the popular
commercial culture in order to avoid Orwellian tyranny.
- Another defender of Madisonian idealswhom we call the reformist 24 compromises Enlightenment values as a
pragmatic measure while firmly believing in them. By contrast, the defender of narrative
truths does not ultimately believe in the Enlightenment, but is willing to advance
"salutary" Madisonian myths.
- The defender of Madisonian ideals withholds constitutional protection from the excesses
of "junk" and pornographic speech. By contrast, when narrative truths are
elevated, their defender protects such speech, but in the name of moderating values.
- For the defender of Madisonian ideals, there can be "noble lies" in
furtherance of discernible truths. By contrast, for the defender of narrative truths, it
is far more difficult to call the fabrication of reality a lie, because there are no
ultimate truths. 25
These bulleted points indicate that the old First Amendment is radically different from
the new "truths" told about it. To defend the former is to attack the latter,
and viceversa. Therefore, it is critical to remain clear minded about the
ramifications of moving from the Madisonian to the postmodern. Let us examine further some
of those ramifications.