The Role of Hypocrisy

The unkept promises of the Enlightenment require apologists of Liberalism to cover up. . . .
Hypocrisy [thus] becomes an integral feature of mature Liberalism.

­Sue Curry Jansen
33

Putting lies aside (if only for a moment), let us consider instead the role of hypocrisy in First Amendment thinking. That is, what are we to make of a liberal democracy that encourages base practices to masquerade as noble principles? Does modern constitutional liberalism depend on hypocrisy to survive? And just how candid can any free speech narrative be?

Eminent philosophers and social scientists have argued that hypocrisy is endemic to life and law. Much in the character of the modern democratic state, they contend, not only allows hypocrisy in governance, but demands it. Correlatively, stringent insistence on truth­telling imperils the health of liberal democracy. 34 The late Professor Judith Shklar, for example, maintained that " [h]ypocrisy is one of the few vices that bolsters liberal democracy." 35 Such hypocrisy stems from the disparity between a polity's creed and its conduct. "This disparity often develops over time as an institution comes to serve purposes other than those for which it was established." 36 As we suggest above, the move from Madisonian truths to narrative ones carries with it the baggage of hypocrisy.

Some of our colleagues acknowledge this underbelly of liberal democracy as revealed in the body of First Amendment theory. 37 For example, Professor Hariman declares: " [T]he lesson to be learned is that any society depends on systematic (although not absolute) inattention to its contradictions, an inattention that is directed mythically . . . ." 38 "Likewise," he adds, "the test of the First Amendment is not so much that it provides an accurate representation of American discursive habits, but that it can provide the rhetorical norms for renewing specific discursive practices." 39 A far less sympathetic Professor Drury observes: "There is no doubt a certain hypocrisy on the part of those who use First Amendment arguments in order to defend [low] speech [practices] . . . ." 40

Granting arguendo the importance of First Amendment narratives, must one also grant the necessity of a hypocritical narrative or myth? Hypocrisy typically enters into these narratives whenever elevated stories are heralded. By contrast, narratives that reflect the popular commercial culture do not depend on such hypocrisy, if only because they more closely align low realism with low idealism. When the ceiling crashes through the floor, hypocrisy is no longer foundational. Liberal democracy of the postmodern variety must suffer a significant degree of narrative hypocrisy because it is unable to free itself altogether of traditional Madisonian values. Sociologist Todd Gitlin­an astute defender of Madisonian liberalism­puts it forcefully: " [T]he immense gravitational field of the Enlightenment is not so casually escaped, even by its critics." 41

prevnav.gif (1564 bytes)
Previous

homenav.gif (1574 bytes)
Article Index

nextnav.gif (1624 bytes)
Next