Education for Cultural Elevation
There is a curious custom in the British Navy:
all the cordage of the Royal Fleet, whether heavy or light,
is twisted so that a red thread runs through whole ropes,
by which even the smallest piece can berecognized as Crown property.
Johann W. von Goethe 45
Can we untangle hypocrisy from Madisonian values by educating ourselves? Several of our colleagues hope so. They attempt to avoid free speech critiques of the popular culture by relying on education, by raising public consciousness, and by refining the tastes of Americans. With the fighting spirit of the late Robert Maynard Hutchins, 46 they tie the fate of America to an Enlightenmentlike faith in education.
Mind their rallying cries:
Robert Hariman: " [T]he direction that I would recommend for resolving the problem of maintaining citizenship . . . in the spirit of civicrepublican reform ought to be developing rhetorical competencies rather than restricting competing forms of expression." 47 . . . " [T]he focal point for reorienting the First Amendment should be protecting and nurturing particular communities that allow the development of the rhetorical competencies required for achieving deliberative judgment in an open society. These communities will range from high schools to electronic networks to . . . talk shows and beyond." 48
David Nyberg: "The institutional failure that deserves more attention here . . . is an educational one; it is the failure to instill . . . a sense of selfdiscipline, a disposition to seek and appreciate excellence , and a belief in the longterm benefits of moderation, or balance in the ways that we live." 49 . . . "The kind of education that we need to combat passive, mindless consumerism and fascination with pornography is exposure to greatness, to excellence." 50
Loyal Rue: "What about the schools? . . . [W]e should not underestimate the possibility that the tastes of American consumers of culture might be elevated by means of education. The educational establishment is still largely independent of the media culture, and increasingly hostile toward it." 51
Our colleagues's appeal on behalf of education is valiant. Narrative heroicism notwithstanding, is theirs a battle that can be won? We wonder whether the education envisioned by our colleagues does not war with a culture ever increasingly steeped in the excesses of the marketplace. To what extent is it likely that the mission of education can stand significantly free of the commercial entertainment culture? Even Professors Nyberg and Rue, as they endorse this campaign, are sober enough to admit that the odds of victory are slim. Nyberg concedes, despite his aspirations, that we are starting from the point of "institutional failure." 52 And Rue's optimism is heavily qualified: "The whole story is likely to be bleak enough, but it just might leave room for a slightly happier ending." 53